Archivio tag: clima

Le religioni muoiono quando gli adepti si annoiano.

Bret Stephens sul Wall Street Journal fa un parallelismo tra il global warming e le religioni, proprio nei giorni in cui a Durban si discute del dopo Kyoto. Prima spiega come sia difficile far morire le religioni (“How do religions die? Probably the don’t…”) e poi spiega:

As with religion, it [global warming] is presided over by a caste of spectacularly unattractive people pretending to an obscure form of knowledge that promises to make the seas retreat and the winds abate. As with religion, it comes with an elaborate list of virtues, vices and indulgences. As with religion, its claims are often non-falsifiable, hence the convenience of the term “climate change” when thermometers don’t oblige the expected trend lines. As with religion, it is harsh toward skeptics, heretics and other “deniers.” And as with religion, it is susceptible to the earthly temptations of money, power, politics, arrogance and deceit.

Cita poi il caso del climategate e delle mail in cui gli scienziati si consigliavano, prima del summit di Copenhagen dello scorso anno, di minimizzare il declino delle teorie catastrofiste:

That’s where the Climategate emails come in. First released on the eve of the Copenhagen climate summit two years ago and recently updated by a fresh batch, the “hide the decline” emails were an endless source of fun and lurid fascination for those of us who had never been convinced by the global-warming thesis in the first place.

But the real reason they mattered is that they introduced a note of caution into an enterprise whose motivating appeal resided in its increasingly frantic forecasts of catastrophe. Papers were withdrawn; source material re-examined. The Himalayan glaciers, it turned out, weren’t going to melt in 30 years. Nobody can say for sure how high the seas are likely to rise—if much at all. Greenland isn’t turning green. Florida isn’t going anywhere.

E, ricollegandosi al discorso iniziale, infila una chiusura deliziosa:

And there is this: Religions are sustained in the long run by the consolations of their teachings and the charisma of their leaders. With global warming, we have a religion whose leaders are prone to spasms of anger and whose followers are beginning to twitch with boredom. Perhaps that’s another way religions die.